Who, What, Where, When, Why…and How

   On NPR, All Things Considered last week, Christina Shokley mentions the classic questions of journalism, or any human story with a logos, and it set us to musin’ about the four causes in Aristotle’s Metaphysics in relation. The classic example, easily seen in an artificial being, is a table: The what is the table, the purpose to read or eat, the material wood or such, and the efficient cause is the human carpenter, with the form in mind to suit the function, setting to work, each thing in order. In our oversimplified account, the formal and final causes go together, and the material and efficient causes go together. In another way, the final and efficient causes occur in time, while the formal and the material occur in space. “Who” is the particular being in a human story, but a story might concern other beings or even, say, a rock that fell and got wedged in a river, etc. Most particular beings, those with extension, taking up space, if you have noticed, are living beings, and this in itself is strange. But the Aristotle leaves it for us to notice that natural being are not as clear regarding the purpose as are artificial beings, things made, mostly by man. The “what” of a thing cannot be understood without its function, and living things have purposes of their own, actions as well as causes. Animals that move themselves have purposes to their actions, and so especially have stories, with a Who What Where When Why, and How!

   When and how both concern time. Where and who concern space, or space as well as time, since all space is at a certain time, and all time that of a certain space. though “what” need not be spatial, and like a verbal noun, might identify a process.

   Earth, air and water are three conditions of matter, while fire, or energy, as an efficient cause. Mater and energy are said to be nonconvertible, and space and time to be inseparably related, while none of these are logos or meaning, which pertains hardly at all to the material and almost entirely to the formal cause. There is no matter without form, even a rock, while there is lots of form without any matter at all, such as the logos of stratification or the eternal truths of math and logic, or the metaphysics of journalism.

I’ll be sure to dig out my Aristotle, Metaph. I.26? and rethink all this, when I get when!

3 thoughts on “Who, What, Where, When, Why…and How

  1. how can a rock thrown in a river take up space when it already exists in the “Now” in the universe, the rock already has its being and space no matter “Where” you throw it lol.

    • Rocks and rivers are somehow less real objects than living thingss. Rocks are more like stuff just lying around, without a clear distinction between what is, for example, “this tree” and “not this tree.” Life is very mysterious. Even biologists cannot define it.
      But even a rock can have a story. I used to think if I were a drop of water, my luck I’d wind up making some dirt clod wet. For like a billion years!

    • I found the Journal of Fr. Marquette, who saw the Algonquian at Mackinac in 1675, and saw the Pottawatomie in Wisconsin, where they went when the Iroquois chased ’em out of Michigan. That’s the only new thing I have to add to the stone story.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s